- Johnny – Joe Paoni
- Tunny – Steve Gonzalez
- Will – Matt Kaiser
- St. Jimmy – Elliot Owens
- Whatsername – Jessica Vaughn
- Heather – Sheree Owens
- Extraordinary Girl – Anja Ward
Ensemble - The Men
- Cam – Cam Cassella
- Connor – Connor Vigeant
- Jesse – Jesse Drake
- Joey – Joey T.
- Logan – Logan Higgins
- Nat – Nat Ward
- Phillip – Phillip Laks
Ensemble - The Women
- Angelica – Angelica Rosenthal
- Caitlin – Caitlin Thistle
- Danielle – Danielle Lepine
- Jen – Jennifer Ryder
- Joanne – Joanne Wood
- Julie – Julie Shea
- Kelly – Kelly Purpura
- Kelsey – Kelsey Rae Marot
- Lo – Lauren Dillon
- Lauren -Lauren Friedman
- Leah -Leah Schwartz
- Sarah – Sarah Wenrich
- Steph – Stephanie Pappas
Orchestra
Guitar - Ken Gray
Guitar and Keyboards - Geoff Gilbert
Bass - Justin McLean
Drums/Conductor - Jeffrey Prescott
Cello - Angelica Rosenthal
Link to production team